Google just launched Bard yesterday. Naturally, we wanted to see how Bard compares to ChatGPT.
To start, we asked both of them to compare themselves to each other.
First, it was Bard’s turn.
Bard Prompt:
How does Bard compare to ChatGPT?
Bard’s answer was the following:
Bard and ChatGPT-4 are both large language models (LLMs) that can generate text, translate languages, and write different kinds of creative content. However, there are some key differences between the two models.
Bard is trained on a dataset of text and code that includes a wider range of topics than ChatGPT-4. This allows Bard to generate more comprehensive and informative responses. For example, Bard can answer questions about current events, science, and history, while ChatGPT-4 is more limited to questions about popular culture and entertainment.
Bard also has a more sophisticated understanding of language. This allows Bard to generate more natural-sounding text and to understand complex instructions. For example, Bard can understand instructions like “Write a poem about a cat” or “Explain the concept of entropy.” ChatGPT-4 is more likely to generate text that sounds robotic or to misunderstand complex instructions.
However, ChatGPT-4 is better at generating creative text formats. For example, ChatGPT-4 can generate code, scripts, musical pieces, email, letters, etc. Bard is not as good at generating these formats.
Overall, Bard is a more comprehensive and informative LLM, while ChatGPT-4 is better at generating creative text formats.
Now let’s ask ChatGPT-4 the same question. As a full disclosure, this is not a fair comparison, as it’s well known that ChatGPT-4 has a knowledge cut-off date of September 2021 and hence does not know about Google’s Bard that is released today. Nevertheless, it was curious to see what answer ChatGPT-4 would give to the same question
Prompt:
How does Bard compare to ChatGPT?
Answer:
As an AI language model, I cannot provide real-time information on specific models or products that may have been developed or released after my knowledge cutoff date in September 2021. However, I can give you a general comparison between the fourth version of ChatGPT and a hypothetical model called “Bard.”
ChatGPT-4 would be an iteration of OpenAI’s GPT series, which are transformer-based language models trained on a massive corpus of text data from the internet. GPT models are designed for various natural language processing tasks, such as generating text, answering questions, translating languages, and summarization.
On the other hand, “Bard” is a hypothetical AI language model that you mentioned. Without any specific information about its architecture, training data, or capabilities, it is difficult to provide an accurate comparison to ChatGPT-4. However, the name “Bard” suggests it might be designed for creative writing or poetry generation.
To compare Bard with ChatGPT-4, you would need to consider several factors, including their respective architectures, training data, and performance on various natural language processing tasks. Additionally, you should examine how well each model generalizes, understands context, and generates coherent responses while maintaining factual accuracy.
If you have any information on the features or capabilities of Bard, I would be happy to help you compare it with the ChatGPT series.
So we followed up with ChatGPT and told it what Bard stated regarding this comparison.
Prompt:
Bard is Google’s LLM AI that was released on March 21, 2023. When asked the same question, Bard answered the following:
Bard and ChatGPT-4 are both large language models (LLMs) that can generate text, translate languages, and write different kinds of creative content. However, there are some key differences between the two models.
Bard is trained on a dataset of text and code that includes a wider range of topics than ChatGPT-4. This allows Bard to generate more comprehensive and informative responses. For example, Bard can answer questions about current events, science, and history, while ChatGPT-4 is more limited to questions about popular culture and entertainment.
Bard also has a more sophisticated understanding of language. This allows Bard to generate more natural-sounding text and to understand complex instructions. For example, Bard can understand instructions like “Write a poem about a cat” or “Explain the concept of entropy.” ChatGPT-4 is more likely to generate text that sounds robotic or to misunderstand complex instructions.
However, ChatGPT-4 is better at generating creative text formats. For example, ChatGPT-4 can generate code, scripts, musical pieces, email, letters, etc. Bard is not as good at generating these formats.
Overall, Bard is a more comprehensive and informative LLM, while ChatGPT-4 is better at generating creative text formats.
Answer:
Thank you for providing the information on Google’s Bard AI. Based on this information, here’s a comparison between Bard and ChatGPT-4:
- Data and knowledge: Bard is trained on a more extensive dataset, covering a wider range of topics than ChatGPT-4. As a result, Bard can generate more comprehensive and informative responses, including current events, science, and history, while ChatGPT-4 may be more limited in these areas.
- Language understanding: Bard reportedly has a more sophisticated understanding of language, which enables it to generate natural-sounding text and comprehend complex instructions better than ChatGPT-4.
- Creative text formats: On the other hand, ChatGPT-4 seems to excel in generating creative text formats, such as code, scripts, musical pieces, emails, and letters, while Bard might not be as proficient in these tasks.
In summary, Bard appears to be a more comprehensive and informative LLM, while ChatGPT-4 has an edge in generating creative text formats. When choosing between the two, the decision should be based on the specific use cases and requirements you have in mind.
That’s nice of ChatGPT-4. Didn’t get competitive, but on the other hand, didn’t provide more specifics either, just rephrased what Bard had to say.
Next step is to regenerate the answers ChatGPT gave for the questions described in our two previous articles. Let’s see how the two differ when asking to generate neighborhood information for an address and ad copies for property descriptions.
Create neighborhood description for a specific property address
To make this comparison fair, we’ll regenerate the neighborhood description with the latest ChatGPT-4. At the time of writing that article, only ChatGPT-3.5 was available for the general public. We’ll use the same randomly generated listing on Zillow
ChatGPT-4 Prompt:
Write a neighborhood description for 56 Walden, Irvine, CA 92620 for a real estate listing
ChatGPT-4 Answer:
Welcome to 56 Walden, a stunning gem nestled in the highly sought-after community of Stonegate in Irvine, CA 92620. This picturesque neighborhood combines the serenity of suburban living with the convenience of a prime location.
Boasting tree-lined streets, meticulously maintained landscaping, and elegant architecture, this idyllic community offers an unparalleled living experience. At its heart is the beautiful Stonegate Park, where residents can enjoy a leisurely stroll, a family picnic, or an invigorating workout. The park also features a children’s playground, basketball courts, tennis courts, and a large pool – providing endless entertainment for residents of all ages.
Convenience is a key attribute of this neighborhood, with top-rated schools such as Stonegate Elementary, Jeffrey Trail Middle School, and Northwood High School just a stone’s throw away. The Woodbury Town Center and Cypress Village Shopping Center are nearby, offering an array of shopping, dining, and entertainment options.
56 Walden is strategically located with easy access to major highways like I-5 and the 133 Toll Road, making it a breeze to travel to the bustling hubs of Orange County, including Irvine Spectrum Center, Tustin Marketplace, and South Coast Plaza.
Safety and a sense of community are integral to the Stonegate lifestyle. The neighborhood is part of the master-planned community of Irvine, which consistently ranks as one of the safest cities in America. With a robust calendar of community events and social gatherings, you’ll quickly feel connected to your neighbors and the surrounding area.
Discover the perfect balance of tranquility and modern living at 56 Walden.
Bard Prompt:
Write a neighborhood description for 56 Walden, Irvine, CA 92620 for a real estate listing
Bard Answer:
56 Walden is a beautiful single-family home in the Stonegate neighborhood of Irvine, CA. This home features four bedrooms, three bathrooms, and a spacious kitchen with stainless steel appliances and granite countertops. The backyard is perfect for entertaining, with a built-in BBQ and a large patio. The Stonegate neighborhood is close to award-winning schools, shopping, and parks. This home is a must-see for anyone looking for a beautiful and move-in ready home in Irvine.
Here are some of the highlights of the neighborhood:
- Award-winning schools: The Stonegate neighborhood is zoned for some of the best schools in Irvine, including Woodbury Elementary School, Portola High School, and Irvine Valley College.
- Shopping and dining: The Stonegate neighborhood is just minutes from the Woodbury Town Center, which features a variety of shops and restaurants.
- Parks and recreation: The Stonegate neighborhood is home to several parks, including the Stonegate Park and the Irvine Valley Community Park.
- Quiet and family-friendly: The Stonegate neighborhood is a quiet and family-friendly area.
This home is perfect for anyone looking for a beautiful and move-in ready home in Irvine. The Stonegate neighborhood is a great place to raise a family, and this home is sure to impress.
While the Zillow listing shows Woodburry as the neighborhood, both ChatGPT and Bard lists talks about Stonegate. What also pops up as the main difference right away is that Google includes property information as well, not just description of the neighborhood. Let’s continue!
ChatGPT Prompt:
Write another paragraph describing point-of-interests near this address, like restaurants, cafes, museums, parks, shopping etc.
ChatGPT Answer:
Living at 56 Walden, you’ll have easy access to an array of popular points-of-interests that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. Foodies will delight in the wide range of restaurants and cafes nearby, offering a variety of international cuisines, from Italian to Thai and everything in between. Local favorites such as Urban Plates, Taquiero Taco Patio, and Fukuda Sushi are just a short drive away, ensuring that residents have an ever-changing culinary scene to explore.
For art and culture enthusiasts, the nearby Irvine Museum Collection and Pretend City Children’s Museum provide inspiring and educational experiences. The Orange County Great Park, a versatile outdoor space, hosts various events throughout the year, including farmers markets, concerts, and sports tournaments.
Shoppers will find retail therapy at its finest at the upscale Irvine Spectrum Center, featuring top brands, boutiques, and entertainment options. The center boasts a variety of amenities, including a movie theater, a Ferris wheel, and a diverse range of dining options.
Nature lovers can venture to the nearby Bommer Canyon and Quail Hill Preserve for picturesque hiking trails, scenic vistas, and a chance to reconnect with the great outdoors. With its prime location, 56 Walden is surrounded by endless opportunities for leisure, entertainment, and cultural exploration, making it the perfect place to call home in the heart of Irvine, CA.
Bard Prompt:
Write another paragraph describing point-of-interests near this address, like restaurants, cafes, museums, parks, shopping etc.
Bard Answer:
Sure, here are some point-of-interests near 56 Walden, Irvine, CA 92620:
- The Woodbury Town Center is a shopping mall with over 120 stores, including Macy’s, Nordstrom, and JCPenney.
- The Irvine Spectrum is an outdoor shopping and entertainment center with over 170 stores, including Apple, Nike, and Sephora.
- The Irvine Valley Community Park is a large park with a variety of amenities, including a playground, a sports field, and picnic areas.
- The Stonegate Park is a smaller park with a playground and a basketball court.
- The Irvine Museum of Contemporary Art is a museum with a collection of contemporary art.
- The Irvine Fine Arts Center is a community arts center with classes and workshops for all ages.
- The Irvine Public Library is a public library with a variety of books, movies, and music.
- The Irvine Civic Center is a government building with a variety of services, including a DMV office and a police station.
These are just a few of the many point-of-interests near 56 Walden, Irvine, CA 92620.
The two AI’s approach starts to differ greatly. Bard tends to prefer bullet-lists and while Google should have an edge with POIs, it feels like it lost the context of our inquiry, i.e. we want to describe the neighborhood for a real estate listing. ChatGPT’s free flow description of the neighborhood amenities feels more subjective but also more interesting and inviting.
ChatGPT Prompt:
Could you describe the school district in detail?
ChatGPT Answer:
The Irvine Unified School District (IUSD) serves the residents of 56 Walden and is renowned for its commitment to academic excellence, innovative teaching methodologies, and a focus on the overall development of students. The district consistently ranks among the top-performing districts in California and has earned national recognition for its achievements.
IUSD comprises a diverse array of schools, including 28 elementary schools, 7 middle schools, and 6 high schools, with additional alternative and adult education programs. The district is dedicated to providing a well-rounded education, offering comprehensive academic curricula, athletics, arts programs, and extracurricular activities to foster student growth and development.
The schools serving 56 Walden include:
- Eastwood Elementary School: Recognized for its nurturing learning environment and strong academic performance, Eastwood Elementary provides a solid foundation for students from kindergarten to grade 6. The school emphasizes critical thinking, creativity, and collaboration, preparing students for success in their future education.
- Sierra Vista Middle School: Serving students from grades 7 to 8, Sierra Vista Middle School offers a challenging and engaging curriculum that promotes intellectual curiosity and personal growth. The school encourages participation in a wide range of activities, including clubs, sports, and community service projects, to help students develop valuable life skills and foster a sense of responsibility.
- Northwood High School: Ranked among the best high schools in California and the nation, Northwood High School is known for its rigorous academic programs, impressive graduation rates, and exceptional college preparation. The school boasts a variety of Advanced Placement (AP) courses, as well as excellent athletic and performing arts
Bard Prompt:
Could you describe the school district in detail?
Bard Answer:
Sure. The Irvine Unified School District is a school district in Irvine, California, United States, that serves the city of Irvine. The district has 44 schools, including 23 elementary schools, 6 middle schools, 5 high schools, and 1 continuation high school. The district serves a population of over 34,000 students.
The Irvine Unified School District is a highly regarded and award-winning school district. The district has been nationally recognized for comprehensive programs in academics, the arts, and athletics. The district has also been recognized for its innovative use of technology in education.
The Irvine Unified School District is committed to providing a quality education for all students. The district offers a variety of programs and services to meet the needs of all students, including English language learners, students with disabilities, and students who are gifted or talented.
The Irvine Unified School District is a great place to raise a family and to send your children to school. The district offers a variety of quality educational programs and services in a safe and supportive environment.
What’s very interesting is how ChatGPT-4 and Bard disagree on basic factual data about how many schools belong to the Irvine Unified School District. A quick check on the Irvine Unified School District website shows 30 elementary schools, 12 middle schools and 7 high schools. Given that IUSD Virtual Academy Middle & High is listed both in the Middle and High-School category, it’s a huge discrepancy nevertheless.
That leads to the question about how reliable both AI are when it comes to basic factual information? It’s known that both of them have a certain knowledge cut-off date, but it should be way more prominently displayed when it comes to showing improper facts, like this.
Therefore it’s important to note it once again: you have to make sure before using any of these AI generated content for your listings that they comply with all laws, regulations and local association rules, just as if you wrote these on your own and that even basic facts are human verified. It is your responsibility as a licensed real estate professional to comply with the law, no matter what the source of content that you publish is.
Leave a Reply